One of the pitfalls I see for wayfinding is something I am reminded of everyday as I drive to work. The expressway I take has an overhead electronic sign that alerts drivers to hazards, accidents, construction, etc.
Most of the time (95%) the sign is “off”… meaning there are no messages being displayed. The other 5% of the time, when there is a message, it is often over-looked for the simple fact that drivers tend to assume there will be no message, so they don’t bother looking at the sign everyday. Another downfall of this type of wayfinding device is that it is stationary. Let’s say there was an accident 10 miles up the road, but yet traffic is flowing smoothly at the point where the sign is located. If the message alerting drivers to the accident is lengthy, most of the information will be missed as motorists zoom by without reading the sign only to get frustrated when they reach the traffic jam closer to the accident. A more effective solution would be a mobile electronic sign.
The advantages of this type of device are that it would create a new visual element in a location where it wasn’t seen before. Something new tends to stick out in the familiarity of day to day life. Also, positioning this sign closer to a construction zone where traffic would tend to be slower would give drivers a chance to read the information. On the other hand, positioning the sign further back down the road, would also give drivers a chance to find an alternate route and avoid a potential rush hour slow down.
Wayfinding can also be implemented online as there are many similarities between physical navigation and website navigation. It is always my goal when I create web sites that the layouts are not only well designed but also easy to get around. There are a number of “rules” to follow in web site design. Navigation or links to other pages in the site are usually found at or near the top and can be either displayed horizontally or vertically. Bread-crumb navigation is often used in larger sites with many layers of page levels to help a user get back to a particular page they were just visiting, or to see how they got to a location on the site.
This blog is also an example of this theory. Although blog navigation is unique to the world wide web in that it catalogs and archives posts and entries, it is still the responsibility of the designer (or blog creator) to provide properly labeled post titles and other information that will allow the readers of the blog to gain access to the information they want to find out about. Even though best practices can be followed in creating online content, Passini states that “The ways people read and understand messages vary with the task and the individual.” Passini p.86. Nothing is truer than that statement. I am in agreement when I find that certain age and societal backgrounds of individuals “make responses to information more complex”. Passini p. 86. I do my best to ensure I meet the requirements of not only the customer but the expectations of the end users as well. After all, you can have the best looking site (or blog) online, but what good is it if no one can find the information they are looking for?
Works cited:
Jacobson, Robert Information Design The Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1999
http://media.mlive.com/kzgazette_impact/photo/0239513-2jpg-07644ff73a5eb061.jpg
http://matchbin-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/public/sites/624/assets/traffic_sign_01.jpg
I too chose Wayfinding. I appreciate what you have shown and discussed here. It discussed areas that I did not present in my blog.
ReplyDeleteHi Paul,
ReplyDeleteYour explaination is effective, clear, convincing and very interesting. The example you chose really described the pros and cons of Wayfinding. The use of those two electronic signs caught my attention right away. I think if the first sign was up and running displaying the problems ahead of the road, it would be helpful as well. I am sure these electronic sign issues do not happen everywhere.
I live in NYC and I take the either the bus or the train. I found this picture that is very helpful to all of us. It is not direct us to go anywhere else but it advises us how patience we must be. It’s related to your electronic sign examples.
http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://nyc.metblogs.com/archives/images/2007/02/train.jpg&imgrefurl=http://nyc.metblogs.com/2007/02/25/automated-l-train-steals-my-heart/&usg=__P6hTxL3tnNigx_TP2fPWAfkcB2w=&h=375&w=500&sz=142&hl=en&start=16&zoom=1&tbnid=8-bG1RtiJXcKJM:&tbnh=122&tbnw=163&ei=qXJpTYGLC4uugQfOyJDMCg&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dmta%2Bnew%2Belectronic%2Bsigns%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DN%26rlz%3D1R2ADFA_enUS360%26biw%3D1135%26bih%3D568%26tbs%3Disch:10%2C584&um=1&itbs=1&iact=hc&vpx=571&vpy=238&dur=2667&hovh=194&hovw=259&tx=133&ty=135&oei=k3JpTaboGsGp8Ab8kcScCw&page=2&ndsp=18&ved=1t:429,r:15,s:16&biw=1135&bih=568
Best,
Victor
Paul,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your blog post. What stood out for me, because I can certainly relate, are the highway signs that don’t often help at all. When driving at 65 mph it is difficult to view a message! If you have a passenger, they can help, but commuters are usually the sole occupant of a car.
My husband and I were traveling home from Lake George NY and somewhere around Albany we saw a sign that the Mid-Hudson Bridge was closed. We decided to take the Kingston Bridge, but when we got off the exit, the normal signs were confusing and there was no follow up emergency sign. We drove all the way to Newburgh and crossed the river there. We were not finding our way very well at all! If one sign tells us to seek an alternate route, there ought to be more to help along the way.
I had not considered this theory in the design of websites and appreciate your expertise in bringing this to light. There are some shopping sites that I dislike because they make it difficult to checkout. And these are some big name stores. They could take a clue from Way finding.
You also mentioned blogs. I have a blog that I think is a decent read, yet my blog has no traffic. I guess I have to tag it better.
~Patricia
I can absolutely see how your blog fits within the Wayfinding theory of Information Design! For instance, you included a vary clear blog title at the top of your page. You've included photos of the text books for this course as well as a direct phrase that tells us (your visitors)that we've reached the correct destination. Additionally, your post explains the pros and cons of Wayfinding very clearly! Thank you for your informative post :)
ReplyDelete